Canada’s modernism poses threat to fundamentalist America 

He came, he spoke, he left.  Just because U.S. president Bush finally ventured north to say soothing things to us, we shouldn’t think that he likes Canada any better than before.

   Image: Hutcheson & Co.

Oh sure, his speech was cleverly written by Canadian right-winger David Frum with inside jokes and quotes from prime ministers.

But Bush’s opinion of us hasn’t changed.  Despite the Canadian content, his speech was really directed to a wider international audience.  He’s trying to polishing his image on the world stage, where he hopes to charm allies into Iraq.  Gone was belligerent unilateralist.  Gone is the cowboy stance – – replaced with a thoughtful, warm, humorous, self-deprecating president who appeals to reason and good will.

Make no mistake about it, Bush still doesn’t like what Canada stands for.

It’s nothing personal.  It’s the same dislike that he has for Americans who voted for his presidential rival, John Kerry.   When Bush looks at a map of North America, we are all on the same side of the border.

On Bush’s map, Democrats and Canadians are all gripped in the same moral decay.  Canada and the northern states, as well as the U.S. west and east coasts, are all mired in a corrupt social morass.

President Bush is fighting to save the soul of America.   He is well positioned to be commander-in-chief of the only real war — the assailed values of the so-called “moral majority.”   He is a born-again Christian and reformed alcoholic.  He is conservative on social issues, favouring  capital punishment,  opposing gay marriage.  He thinks that decriminalization of marijuana is the road to ruin.

In other words, Bush is against the progressive values that Canadians (and many Americans) stand for.  Canada is a outward-looking, multicultural, modern society with strong support for social programs like health care.

The president perceptions are correct.  There really is a difference between Canada and the Bush’s America.

Bush sees the gap better than many Canadians do.  According to polls, some of us think the two countries are converging.  Canadian pollster Michael Adams has found that the continental divide is widening.  Canadian and the U.S. values are diverging, not converging.  The divergence can be summed up by two words — religiosity and patriarchy.

“Canadians have more confidence in their ability to make moral decisions without deferring to religious authority,” says Adams.  As a percentage,  twice as many Americans go to church weekly as Canadians, twice as many believe the Bible is literally true, and twice as many say religion is important to them.

In the area of patriarchy, Americans are twice likely to agree with the statement “the father of the family must be master in his own house.”  These are not superficial views.  All kinds of values follow the belief in that statement, including strident individualism and belief that the president is the patriarch of the nation.

Ideas represent mental postures that guide Canadians and Americans though everyday life.   Canadians believe in a pragmatic, multilateral approach to problem-solving.  “The moralistic narrative of absolute good and evil that wins many hearts and minds south of the border doesn’t work in Canada,” says Adams.

Bush’s America is threatened by Canada — not from terrorists who could cross to border to the U.S. but from modern ideas.  The psychoanalyst Robert Young has studied the psychology of the moral majority, many who are religious fundamentals.

Fundamentalists see their “traditional” way of life under attack by modern secular culture.  They fear annihilation of their values, and withdraw from mainstream society.

“When people feel under threat,” says Young, “they simplify; in a reduced state people cannot bear uncertainty.”  Fundamentalists see their struggle as cosmic war of good and evil.  They find comfort in sacred texts and spiritual leaders.

This siege mentality has been exacerbated since the attacks of September 11.   Before, it was only secular U.S. culture that was a threat to fundamentalists.  Now it’s coming from all over the world — Muslims, Arabs, liberals, thinkers, socialists, actors, and musicians.

What’s at stake for the moral majority is its very existence. “There is a war waging in America. The battle is over values, beliefs and the cultural basis of western civilization” says Louis Sheldon, founder of the Traditional Values Coalition.

The U.S. can defend it’s borders from terrorists, but it is defenceless against the psychological terror of their own making.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.